Freshly baked pizza
Serving Sherman, IL & Surrounding Communities

Authentic Italian Flavor.
Baked to Perfection.

Welcome to Sam's Too Pizza. Freshly kneaded dough, grandmother's slow-simmered marinara, and rich Wisconsin mozzarella on every dish.

Call Us217-496-2374
Location312 Crossing Dr, Sherman
HoursMon-Thu 11-9 | Fri-Sat 11-10
Quality100% Mozzarella & Fresh Dough
Chef's Choice

Signature Italian Specialties

Explore All 20+ Menu Items
Specialty Pizza
4.9

Supreme Pizza

Sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, hamburger, olives, mushroom, onion, green pepper, and mozzarella.

Starting at$15.29
Order Now
Specialty Pizza
4.9

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo chicken, onion, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese.

Starting at$10.95
Order Now
Specialty Pizza
4.9

Taco Pizza

Taco sauce, taco meat, cheddar, and mozzarella, topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, and sour cream.

Starting at$10.95
Order Now
Specialty Pizza
4.9

Chicken Ranch Pizza

Ranch sauce, grilled chicken, tomato, onion, green pepper, cheddar, and mozzarella.

Starting at$10.95
Order Now
The Sam's Too Promise

Made Fresh Daily with Uncompromised Italian Quality

From our famous toasted garlic knots to slow-cooked lasagna and thick-crust pizzas loaded with toppings, every recipe comes directly from our family kitchen to your dining table.

100% Real Wisconsin Cheese
Scratch-Made Secret Marinara
Daily Hand-Rolled Dough
Fresh Vegetables & Meats
Scenic town in Italy
Warm Trattoria Dining Atmosphere

Join us for cozy indoor seating or order fast takeaway for the family.

Italian catering spread
Events & Gatherings

Hosting a Party or Business Event?
Let Sam's Too Handle the Catering

We cater birthday parties, office luncheons, family reunions, and sports celebrations. Choose from large pans of lasagna, ziti, toasted garlic knots, fresh garden salads, and dessert platters.